Both doola and Firstbase register a brand-new LLC and then apply for your EIN — days to weeks, especially for non-residents without an SSN. USLLCGlobal does the opposite: we transfer a ready-made Wyoming LLC, EIN already issued, into your name within 24 hours. Here's the honest, line-by-line comparison — including where doola and Firstbase beat us.
Last updated: June 2026 · By Shepherd Nyakudya, Founder of USLLCGlobal
If you're reading this, you've done the hard part: you want a US LLC, you understand you need an EIN and a US bank account to make it useful, and you've narrowed your options to doola, Firstbase, and us. The remaining question is the one each company's own website makes surprisingly hard to answer: which one actually gets you operational fastest, for the lowest total cost over 12 months?
We are USLLCGlobal, so this page is not neutral — but it is honest. Where doola or Firstbase do something better than we do, we say so. The single biggest structural difference is this: doola and Firstbase sell you a formation process; we sell you a finished company. Their clock starts when they file. Our company already exists, already has its EIN, and only needs transferring to you.
The table most comparison pages bury at the bottom — because it's the only thing most readers want.
| What you're buying | doola | Firstbase | USLLCGlobal |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you actually get | Forms a NEW LLC | Forms a NEW LLC | Ready-made LLC + EIN, or a new one |
| EIN already exists? | No — applied for after formation | No — applied for after formation | Yes — already issued |
| Time to a usable company | Days–weeks (EIN at standard speed) | Days–weeks (EIN "expedited", undefined) | Within 24 hours (ready-made) |
| Starting price | $297/year | $399 one-time | $1,000 ready-made · $549 new |
| State filing fee included? | No — extra | Yes — "zero filing fees" | Yes — included |
| Registered agent included | Yes — bundled | No — $299/year extra | Yes — 1 year |
| Same-day EIN at entry price | No (faster only on $1,499+ plans)1 | Not specified | Already issued (ready-made) |
| Bank guidance (Mercury / Wise / Relay) | Mercury only mentioned | Bank access referenced | Mercury, Wise, Relay walkthroughs |
| Stripe setup help | Not bundled | Not bundled | Step-by-step walkthrough |
| Form 5472 (Year 1) | Tax & Compliance plan ($1,499/yr) | Tax add-on ($899/yr) | Included in Complete ($999 one-time) |
| Money-back guarantee | Partial — error refund only | Not published | Yes — money-back guarantee |
| Privacy | Depends on state | Depends on state | Wyoming — no public owner register |
| Support | Email + scheduled calls (paid plans) | "Lifetime expert support" (channel unclear) | WhatsApp + UK & US phone |
| Best for | A polished dashboard + bundled bookkeeping | VC-style mailroom & long-term subscription | Founders who need to start trading now |
1. Trustpilot reviewers report 5+ week EIN delays even on paid doola plans — including a December 2024 1-star reviewer who waited 5 weeks before discovering the EIN application had not been submitted at all. See the verbatim quote bank below.
doola has a slicker dashboard with bookkeeping, invoicing, and an AI Co-Founder feature bundled in, plus a Mercury cashback partnership ($150–300 in rewards depending on plan). If you want one login that does formation + books + tax filings, they do that better than we do. Firstbase has a genuinely useful mailroom service ($35–50/month) for a US business address with mail scanning, and claims 30,000+ companies served — serious volume we can't match yet.
We're a focused specialist that hands you a finished company, not a platform. If the platform experience and a long-term subscription relationship are what you want, doola or Firstbase are reasonable picks. If you want to start trading this week with a company that already has its EIN, that's us.
Verbatim quotes from public Trustpilot 1- and 2-star reviews, pulled April 28, 2026. Sample: 92 doola + 95 Firstbase reviews. Both sit at roughly a 50/50 split between 5-star and 1-star — there's no neutral middle.
Quotes are verbatim from public Trustpilot reviews. We are not asserting these as fact about the companies — verify directly: doola.com on Trustpilot · firstbase.io on Trustpilot. Attribution is limited to rating and month/year to avoid identifying individual reviewers.
This is where ready-made wins outright. doola and Firstbase both have to get you an EIN after the LLC is formed. For a non-resident without an SSN, the IRS only issues an EIN by phone or fax — there's no instant online route — so "standard speed" can mean 4–6 weeks of mailed or faxed processing. doola's own pricing gates a "faster EIN" behind its $1,499/year Tax & Compliance plan; Firstbase says "expedited EIN" without defining it.
A ready-made USLLCGlobal company skips the wait entirely: the EIN already exists. It was issued when the company was formed, and it transfers to you with the company within 24 hours. You can't open Mercury, apply to Stripe, or sign up for most US SaaS as a business without an EIN — so a 2–3 week EIN delay is a 2–3 week delay on everything. Ready-made removes that delay before it starts. (Prefer a custom name? Our new-formation path still does a same-day EIN by phone as Third Party Designee on the day the LLC is approved.)
All three point you at Mercury — the obvious 2026 choice for non-residents. doola has a Mercury cashback partnership ($150–300) that's a real benefit if you're depositing early. Firstbase references bank access without a specific walkthrough. USLLCGlobal walks you through Mercury, Wise, and Relay with KYC document prep and exactly what to write in the "business activity" field — and helps with Wise as a fallback when Mercury rejects (which happens to roughly 1 in 5 non-resident applicants). If Mercury's cashback alone is worth $200–300 to you, that single line item leans doola — we flag it because it would be dishonest not to.
Form 5472 is mandatory for every foreign-owned single-member LLC, even with $0 revenue. Missing it triggers a $25,000 penalty per year — the single biggest compliance trap for non-residents (see the IRS's About Form 5472). All three can handle it; the difference is how it's priced:
If you'll run the LLC for 5+ years and want one dashboard handling everything every year, the subscription models eventually become more convenient. What we're better at: getting you through Year 1 — the year the most goes wrong — for less than half what they charge.
The third option people consider, Stripe Atlas, creates Delaware C-Corps. Correct for someone heading into Y Combinator; tax-disastrous for a solo non-resident — 21% corporate tax plus 15–30% dividend withholding, vs 0% US tax on a properly structured non-resident LLC. If anyone tells you Atlas is the default best choice for non-residents, they don't understand non-resident taxation.
Skip the formation-then-EIN wait entirely. Pick a ready-made Wyoming LLC ($1,000), verify, and start trading today. Prefer a custom name? We register a brand-new LLC for $549 — state fee, registered agent and same-day EIN included.
For a non-resident wanting LLC + EIN + bank guidance + Form 5472 in Year 1.
| Cost line | doola (Tax & Compliance) | Firstbase (Start + Agent + Tax) | USLLCGlobal (Complete) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Formation / company fee | $1,499/yr (sale) | $399 one-time | $999 one-time |
| State filing fee (Wyoming) | ~$100 extra | Included | Included |
| Registered agent | Bundled | $299/year | Included Y1 |
| EIN | Included (faster on this plan) | Included ("expedited") | Same-day / already issued |
| Form 5472 + 1120 pro-forma (Y1) | Bundled | $899/yr add-on | Included Y1 |
| Bank guidance | Mercury cashback | Bank access referenced | Mercury / Wise / Relay |
| Stripe walkthrough | Self-service | Self-service | Step-by-step |
| Realistic Year 1 total | ~$1,599 | ~$1,597 | $999 |
That's roughly a $600 saving for the same end state — an operational LLC with EIN, bank guidance, and Year 1 Form 5472 filed. Don't need Form 5472 in Year 1? Our new-formation $549 one-time package gets you to "operational with a bank account" for about $1,000 less than doola's equivalent. Already have an LLC and just need the EIN? Our EIN-only package is $199 with a money-back guarantee. And if speed is the priority over a custom name, the $1,000 ready-made company already has its EIN — live within 24 hours, no formation wait at all.
Heading into Y Combinator or holding a VC term sheet? None of these three is your answer — go to Stripe Atlas for the Delaware C-Corp. Running the LLC for 5+ years and value the dashboard + bookkeeping bundle over the price gap? doola is genuinely a better long-term subscription platform than we are. Already in the US and want a local CPA-led service? Find a local CPA — we're built for speed and for non-residents.
Keep reading: Ready-made vs. forming a new LLC · doola vs Stripe Atlas · Wyoming LLC · All comparisons